Standard or Tankless Water Heater?

If it’s time to replace your existing water heater or if you are building a new home, talk to a good plumbing contractor who handles water heater installation and repair about whether a standard tank-type water heater or a tankless water heater would be the best choice for your situation.

Tank-type water heaters have been the standard for residential applications for decades, but in the last ten years or so tankless or “on-demand” water heater have become a popular choice for a water heating system.  The allure of tankless water heaters include lower energy costs and an endless supply of hot water.  In addition, tankless water heaters take up less space than standard water heaters.

There are advantages and disadvantages of both types of water heaters to consider before choosing a system.  The initial outlay for a tank-type water heater is much less than for a tankless water heating system.  In addition, modern tank-type water heaters are more efficient than those produced ten years ago which reduces the difference in energy usage between the two types of water heaters.

Tankless water heaters are more efficient and use less energy because, unlike standard water heaters, they do not constantly keep a tank of water hot.  They only heat water as it is needed.  However, with an electric tankless water heater, some of the cost savings can be lost if hot water is used during peak demand times and the utility company charges a demand premium.  This is not a concern for natural gas or propane tankless water heaters.

Also, a tankless water heater produces endless hot water only as long as the flow rate is not exceeded.  If the tankless water heater is undersized, then using too much hot water such as doing laundry while taking a shower or two showers running at the same time can be a problem.

Disadvantages of Electric Tankless Water Heaters

The allure of unlimited hot water and the thought of saving energy on water heating costs have led many homeowners to consider installing a tankless water heater to replace their conventional storage type water heater.  Tankless water heaters can be a great choice for many applications, but they are not a “no-brainer” type of purchase especially if you are considering an electric tankless water heater.  There are some disadvantages to consider before you take the plunge on a tankless water heater installation.

A storage type water heater wastes energy by continuously keeping a tank of water hot, even when there is no demand for hot water.  Tankless water heaters (also called “on-demand” water heaters) save energy by only heating water when it is needed.  Since they heat water on demand, they can continuously supply hot water and will not run out like a storage type water heater.

However, if you are considering an electric tankless water heater, you may not see any cost savings on your energy bill and may even spend more on electric energy for water heating.  The reason is that electric tankless water heaters use a lot of electricity when hot water is needed which is often during peak usage periods such as during the day when people are bathing or doing laundry.

Some utility companies charge higher rates for electricity usage during high demand periods.  You may end up using less electricity with the tankless water heater, but paying higher rates for electricity which would wipe out any energy cost savings.

In addition, because they use large amounts of electricity when they are heating water, installing an electric tankless water heater may require upgrading the electrical wiring in your home.  Your plumbing professional can help you decide if an electric tankless water heater is good choice for your home.